Press
Jumping into the (rental) pool: Evaluating the pros and cons for property investors.article

For property investors building portfolios of income-generating apartments, choosing between self-management, a conventional vacation rental operator or a professionally managed rental pool can influence occupancy, operating costs and investment returns. The choice is equally important for property developers. Selecting the right aparthotel operator and operating model can shape how a project is designed and positioned for investment buyers.
While traditional buy-to-let investors typically earn income from individual properties, rental pools offer a different approach by combining participating apartments into a centrally managed hotel operation.
Rael Phillips, CEO of aparthotel management company Totalstay, says investors should look beyond traditional short-term letting and consider the commercial advantages of professional aparthotel management.
"There's a fundamental difference between managing bookings for individual apartments and operating an aparthotel as a hospitality business. A professional aparthotel operator brings together revenue management, distribution, guest services, and operational expertise to maximise the property's earning potential. For investors building portfolios, that distinction becomes increasingly important."
In a sectional title rental pool structured around Participation Quotas (PQ), owners receive a share of pooled hotel revenue based on their unit size, similar to how sectional title levies are calculated. Income is distributed after applicable operating expenses and management fees have been deducted.
Unlike independently managed apartments, where income depends on bookings for each individual unit, a rental pool allows owners to benefit from the performance of the entire aparthotel. This can reduce exposure to individual vacancies, although income remains dependent on the aparthotel's overall performance.
"The advantage is that apartments are no longer competing individually for the same bookings. Instead, they form part of a coordinated aparthotel offering, with marketing, pricing, availability and distribution managed across the inventory," explains Phillips.
Professional aparthotel management provides access to centralised reservations, marketing, revenue management and operational infrastructure. By managing units collectively rather than individually, operators can accommodate corporate, leisure, group and extended-stay demand, while creating efficiencies in pricing, housekeeping, maintenance and guest services.
"Scale changes the economics of accommodation management. A professionally operated portfolio benefits from distribution channels, systems and expertise that may not be commercially viable for an individual investor to access independently or through a conventional vacation rental operator," says Phillips.
"However, scale alone doesn't guarantee better returns. Location, market demand, operating costs and the competence of the operator remain critical."
While rental pools offer potential benefits, they also involve trade-offs. Owners may be required to comply with common furnishing and maintenance standards, have less control over day-to-day decisions and face restrictions on personal use.
Operating expenses reduce distributable income, while a downturn in overall demand across the property affects all participating owners.
Self-management offers greater flexibility over pricing, bookings and expenditure, but it also requires investors to take responsibility for marketing, guest management, maintenance and vacancy risk.
"An investor might generate higher gross revenue independently, but that doesn't necessarily translate into a better net return. Equally, paying a management fee doesn't automatically improve performance. The comparison needs to account for operating costs, vacancies and the time required to manage the properties," says Phillips.
Beyond the financial considerations, Phillips says investors should pay particular attention to the operator responsible for managing their property. He recommends evaluating four key areas:
Commercial expertise: Does the operator actively manage pricing, occupancy and distribution across multiple market segments?
Operational capability: Are professional guest services, housekeeping, maintenance and quality controls in place to maintain consistent standards?
Financial transparency: Can the operator demonstrate actual performance, explain its fees and provide detailed reporting on revenue, expenses and net returns?
Track record and asset protection: Does the operator have proven experience managing comparable properties, maintaining standards and protecting long-term asset value?
Investors should also understand how pooled revenue is distributed, which expenses are deducted, their refurbishment obligations and any restrictions on personal use or exiting the arrangement.
"Investors often focus on the management fee rather than the net return. A cheaper operator isn't necessarily a better operator. What matters is the ability to generate revenue, control costs and protect the underlying asset over time," says Phillips.
The property's suitability is equally important. Location, market demand and building infrastructure all influence performance, regardless of the operating model.
For property developers, incorporating an aparthotel operating model during the planning phase can influence building design, shared facilities and the infrastructure required to support efficient operations.
"An aparthotel has different operational requirements from a conventional residential development. Decisions made during the design phase can have a direct impact on operating efficiency, guest experience and ultimately the property's commercial performance," says Phillips.
"Rental pools are generally better suited to commercially minded investors who want an experienced aparthotel operator to manage their assets and maximise income potential. For those who prefer greater flexibility, want to furnish their apartments themselves or intend to use them regularly, the model may not be the right fit. Ultimately, it comes down to whether you view the property primarily as an income-generating investment or an asset you want to use on your own terms," Phillips concludes.
ENDS
About Totalstay™
With more than a decade of experience, Totalstay has helped pioneer and refine the aparthotel model, combining the space and independence of apartment living with the service, consistency and operational standards of a hotel.
Today, Totalstay creates and manages a curated portfolio of aparthotels, serviced apartments and other professionally managed stays. It works across different ownership structures, from rental pools within sectional title developments to purpose-designed aparthotels operated on behalf of single owners, developers and institutional property owners.
Behind every property is Totalstay’s centralised operating hub, bringing together reservations, revenue management, marketing, finance, operations, technology and training. This integrated model creates economies of scale and enables each asset to operate as a unified hospitality experience, supported by hotel-level services tailored to each property.
The result is a complete aparthotel experience that delivers for guests while supporting the asset's performance and long-term value.


